Spectra as a classical phenomenon, and the Einstein classical program
📄 arXiv:2606.19414 · 📥 PDF · 2026-06-17 · nlin.CD
Authors: Andrea Carati [arXiv · scholar] , Luigi Galgani [arXiv · scholar] , Fabrizio Gangemi [arXiv · scholar]
🕰 Orloj analysis
Tento článek tvrdí, že klasické výpočty dokáží překvapivě dobře reprodukovat infračervená spektra iontových krystalů (LiF), a to dokonce lépe než současné kvantové modely při vyšších teplotách. Naznačuje, že s konceptem nulové energie Nernsta může klasická fyzika vysvětlit i nízkoteplotní spektra, čímž potenciálně posouvá Einsteinův klasický program k odvození kvantové fyziky z realistické klasické teorie.
💡 Práce představuje vysoce novátorský a potenciálně hodnotný pokus o redefinici hranic mezi klasickou a kvantovou fyzikou, zpochybňující dlouholeté předpoklady.
✓ falsifiable, limit_reductions
⚠ Comparison to 'presently available' quantum models may be limited, Ambitious 'Einstein Classical Program' goal is notoriously difficult
✗ Strong claims about outperforming quantum models without detailed evidence in abstract, Reliance on re-interpretation of zero-point energy within classical physics without immediate justification
📄 Abstract
According to Born (\emph{Atomic Physics, page 103}), spectra are \emph{``quantum phenomena, which from a classical standpoint are perfectly unintelligible''}. However we illustrate results on classical calculations of infrared spectra of ionic crystals (actually LiF) which show that the situation is much more complex. Indeed it turns out that: 1) At room temperature and at higher ones (up to 1060 K) the classical computations reproduce the experimental data, even better than the \emph{presently available} quantum ones do; 2) At lower temperatures (even at 7.5 K), the classical computations reproduce pretty well the data, if one accepts the idea advanced in 1916 by Nernst (the inventor of the third principle) that zero-point energy has room in classical physics too. It is eventually pointed out that the mentioned results might be regarded as a first step towards an implementation of the Einstein Classical Program, which aims at deducing quantum physics (admittedly the correct theory) from a realistic theory. In fact, we are considering the Einstein classical program in the extreme version in which the realistic theory is just (\emph{essentially, see below}) classical electrodynamics of matter in bulk, involving phase space orbits, solutions of Newton equations. An Appendix is devoted to illustrate the Nernst approach, which concerns also the relation between equipartition and Planck's law.