Beyond black hole spectroscopy: Quasinormal mode contamination by massless scalars
📄 arXiv:2607.08619 · 📥 PDF · 2026-07-09 · gr-qc
Authors: Miguel Yulo Asuncion [arXiv · scholar] , Giovanni D'Addario [arXiv · scholar] , Thomas P. Sotiriou [arXiv · scholar]
🕰 Orloj analysis
Tento článek zkoumá znečištění signálu z dozvuku černých děr (quasinormal modes - QNM) bezhmotnými skalárními poli v teoriích za hranicemi Obecné relativity, konkrétně v rámci Horndeskiho akce. Autoři ukazují, že za určitých předpokladů o skalární amplitudě je vazba mezi skalárem a Gaussovou-Bonnetovou invariantou jediným členem přispívajícím k posunům frekvence i znečištění signálu.
💡 Práce přináší důležité upřesnění pro interpretaci budoucích gravitačních vlnových pozorování, rozlišující mezi posuny frekvence a kontaminací signálu novými poli, což je klíčové pro testování modifikované gravitace.
Categories:
GRV-4
MET-1
THE-18
GRV-3
PRT-1
GRV-2
✓ falsifiable, limit_reductions, modest_claims
⚠ Relaxed assumption about scalar amplitude suppression
📄 Abstract
Testing General Relativity (GR) with black hole ringdowns has conventionally focused on attempting to detect shifts away from the quasinormal mode (QNM) frequencies of the Kerr metric. It has recently been argued, however, that the ringdown signal will also be contaminated with the QNM frequencies of any new fields that are present in a beyond-GR scenario, provided that they couple nonminimally to gravity. We study black hole perturbations for the shift-symmetric Horndeski action, which includes all interactions between a massless scalar and gravity that lead to second order equations upon variation. We perturb linearly in the field and also employ a perturbative expansion in the scalar charge per unit black hole mass, $q$. Assuming that the scalar amplitude is suppressed by $q$, we demonstrate that, to order $q^2$, the coupling between the scalar and the Gauss-Bonnet invariant is the only term that contributes to both frequency shifts and contamination, and that the two effects appear at the same perturbative order. If the assumption about the suppression of the scalar amplitude is relaxed, contamination can appear at leading order in $q$, and hence dominate over frequency shifts. In this case, contamination also receives subleading corrections from an additional coupling